Teen Murder Suspect Could Be Tried As Adult

October 17, 2013
By

 

Hershman was found deceased in her West Ellis Street Home on December 30

Hershman was found deceased in her West Ellis Street Home on December 30

A hearing was held Wednesday to determine if a teen accused of murdering a Milan woman should be tried as an adult.

The 16-year-old teen was allegedly involved in the shooting of 68-year-old Nancy Hershman, of Milan, during a break-in at Hershman’s home on December 30.

Three individuals testified and offered evidence of whether the teen should remain in the juvenile court system or be waived to adult court.

A clinical psychologist and a psychiatrist presented testimony on their assessment of the mental condition of the teenager. According to the Versailles Republican, both professionals recommended the defendant remain in the juvenile system as it offers a better chance for rehabilitation.

An officer from a juvenile detention center in Muncie was called to the stand. The officer recounted numerous violations the teen has been cited for while housed there. The Versailles Republican says the teen was eventually sent to the Department of Corrections due to poor behavior.

Prosecutors argue that if the teen was age 16 at the time of the alleged crime, he would automatically be tried as an adult. The teen turned 16 on December 31, one day after Hershman was killed.

The defendant and the state now have ten days to submit their Findings of Fact and Conclusion to Ripley County Judge Carl Taul. The judge will then decide whether the 16-year-old should be waived to adult court, and if so, the identity of the teen boy will be released.

The teen, along with Sean Nichols, 15, and Allison Moore, 22, drove from Ohio to Ripley County on December 29. They first broke into the home of a Cross Plains man and allegedly robbed him.

In the early morning hours of December 30, police say they traveled to Milan and broke into Hershman’s home. Nancy Hershman was fatally shot during the alleged break-in.

In March, the case against Sean Nichols was waived into adult court by Ripley County Judge Carl Taul.

Listen Live

Upcoming Events

May
22
Fri
5:00 pm KIWANIS CARNIVAL- MAY 22-23-24 @ Batesville Village Green
KIWANIS CARNIVAL- MAY 22-23-24 @ Batesville Village Green
May 22 @ 5:00 pm – May 24 @ 11:00 pm
Fri-Sun, May 22-24      Fun for the whole family with rides, games and tasty treats on the Batesville Village Green starting at 5 PM.  No adm. chg. Jim Hortemiller (812) 934-5267  OR   Dennis Harmeyer, (812) 934-3616. Cost if for ‘Ride bracelet’. Rides-Games – FOOD – Fun! Proceeds benefit the Kiwanis Programs for local Children & Senior Citizens. Friday 5:00-11:00  ($15) Saturday 12:00 – 5:00  ($10)  &  5:00 – 11:00  ($15) Sunday 1:00 – 6:00  ($12)
May
23
Sat
8:00 am Greg “Big Man” Andres Memorial G... @ Country View Golf Course
Greg “Big Man” Andres Memorial G... @ Country View Golf Course
May 23 @ 8:00 am
The Greg “Big man” Andres Memorial Golf Outing will be held at the Country View Golf Course in Dover, Indiana, on Saturday, May 23 with tee times at 8:00 am and 1:30 pm. Cost is $45.00 per person, includes golf, cart, and chicken dinner afterwards. Proceeds go to the Greg Andres/NDCC Scholarship Fund. For more information contact Debbie Zimmer at 513-407-0455 or daezimmer44@hotmail.com. Dinners available for purchase for non-golfers. We are presenting 2 -$500 scholarships as of now — 1 to a ECHS Senior and 1 to a FCHS Senior — names are being kept private until after the scholarship night.
8:30 am Mental Health Training @ St. Paul United Methodist Church
Mental Health Training @ St. Paul United Methodist Church
May 23 @ 8:30 am – 4:00 pm
A psychological first aid for mental health training, open to the public, is May 23 from 8:30 am – 4:00 pm at St. Paul United Methodist Church in Sunman. For more information contact Janice Hosmer at 812-654-2180 or jehosmer48@gmail.com.

View Calendar