Jump to
Press alt + / to open this menu

Home
Photos
Reviews
Menu
Posts
Videos
Events
About
Community
Create a Page
Photos
Image may contain: outdoor
Image may contain: night, sky and outdoor
Image may contain: 2 people, people smiling, people sitting and indoor
See All
Reviews
234 Reviews
People talk aboutbreakfast buffet, meatloaf and soup
Tell people what you think
Jama Linkel-Cleghorn
· June 18, 2017
Unfortunately this rating was after my 2nd poor experience for breakfast. My first experience was the week they opened. So, I thought we would try it again. ...Same unsatisfactory experience. One person at my table ordered pancakes, they came out slightly uncooked. Enough that they only ate the edges. Same situation for another guest with me that ordered french toast. Could only eat the edges. This all could have been fixed by a more attentive waitress. If she would have even came to the table once after we received our food (from someone other than our waitress) - maybe she would have noticed people not eating. Received cold coffee, just an all around poor experience. Very disappointed, and I will not be returning. See More
Connie Crissman
· September 14, 2017
Ate there with a group on September 13. My neighbors were happy with their sandwiches (chicken salad and Reuben) but my other friend thought the salmon tacos w...ere overpriced for the amount and my roasted chicken with gnocchi should have been called gnocchi with a touch of chicken and vegetables. Way too much pasta to be excellent in taste. Our waiter did not refill our water glasses or offer a refill on coffee. He seemed clueless on service. I will not make an effort to stop there again. See More
Sylinda Wright Fallis
· September 7, 2017
We went here for dinner several weeks ago. We were very pleasantly surprised with the new décor. Much more modern and elegant than we were expecting. Our ser...ver was Melissa and she was excellent! My husband and father both got the Best Wurst platters and thought they were very good. My mother got the beef stroganoff and liked it. I had the chicken gnocchi - was good but very filling. We shared the beer cheese appetizer and it was excellent. My husband had the onion soup and, though sweeter than expected, very nice! Will definitely be back! See More
Diana Bergen Thornburg
· March 12, 2017
Our party of 4 visited the Sherman House last evening for the first time since it reopened. I was so excited to hear of the reopening - this was a favorite pla...ce of my parents - their "Go to" place for very special occasions. Upon hearing my stories of visits here, our 12 year old grandson decided this was where he wanted his birthday dinner. Everything about our visit was great - excellent food, service, and decor. I was so happy to see the decor had essentially remained the same as I remember. We had early dinner reservations so were the first to be seated in our dining area but the entire restaurant was busy by the time we left. I have to recommend the onion soup - it was sooo good!! Two in our group had the Sauerbraten, one had the roasted pork, and I had the Ruby Red Trout. All meals were delicious. Nothing but empty plates at our table. Our grandson opted for desert - the Creme Brulee - and nothing but rave reviews for it as well. Even our after dinner coffee was wonderful. Our server, Ashwin, was very attentive and effecient despite being increasingly busy as the evening progressed. We drove 80 miles to eat here and do not regret our decision at all! In fact, we are already talking about when we can visit next. See More
Donna Weber
· August 19, 2017
We had lunch at The Sherman today. It was amazing! I had the Munich burger, and it was perfectly cooked and tasted awesome! It is beautifully done inside... our waitress was friendly and the service was great...awesome dining experience! We will definitely be back!
Jeff Shroyer
· June 23, 2017
Been eating here since 1991, coming from Dayton, OH; ate at the new Black Forest Bar. Thoroughly enjoyed the Best Wurst platter along with a fresh wedge salad drenched in blue cheese dressing! Awesome beer and wine selection with friendly, prompt, efficient service!
Mark Belcher
· July 18, 2017
I am from Virginia Beach Virginia and I have been in town; for two weeks now, for training. Every weekday; since I've been here, I have been eating lunch at t...he Sherman House. I have found the personnel to be friendly; the service fantastic; the food wonderful and the prices extremely reasonable. I can see why this restaurant has been a pillar in the community of Batesville. I am asking all Christians to pray for the employees of this resturant as well as the business. May God bless them and keep this business profitable so it will continue to be a shining family resturant for the people of Batesville to gather. See More
Gabrielle Jones
· May 2, 2017
The server was sweet but clueless. Ordered crab dip as an appetizer. It was runny and the chips were stale. The burger description makes you think you're gettin...g an awesome house made patty. Nope it was a preformed patty. Not what I expected a seasoned chef to allow out of his kitchen. On a positive note the deserts are awesome! See More
Richard Fromme
· September 3, 2017
Five of us went for Sunday Brunch last week around 2:00pm. We called aheah of time and they said the brunch was served until 3:00pm. Surprise.....no brunch. We ...all ordered something different from the menu so we could compare notes And we all agreed that the food was sub-standard in all areas. Even compared to restaurants of supposed lesser quality. Not well decorated and the service was poor at best. At least the place was clean!!! See More
Paula Schaumburg
· June 20, 2017
We took my parents for Fathers day, the food was very good and the waitress was great. She even noticed that our son was ready to eat and getting grouchy, so she brought out his dinner first. Very grateful for her empathy.
Tasheena Griego
· July 8, 2017
Our waitress was very nice! Our margaritas were so yummy!! Our food was burnt thou😩The chicken tenders were overly defried and our burger was pretty much black even thou I asked for medium. Other then that was great!
Eva Marie Forrester-Pullen
· June 19, 2017
I was not impressed with prime Rib I ordered it med it came out close to rare server did not even offer butter for my roll and I don't think I will revisit this establishment
Ben Knott
· April 15, 2017
I ate here last night for the first time. I am not kidding when I say this. The New York Strip is seriously the best steak I've ever had. I usually ask for stea...k sauce anywhere I go.. Ruth Chris.. St Elmos... I thought, let's see how this steak is without anything.. OMG! It was so Juicy and tender is was like butter, melted in your mouth! Also had the beer cheese and pretzels I believe it was, also very good! Service was excellent! Very clean friendly environment! I highly recommend if you've never been here that you go. I was in town for a soccer game as I live in Columbus Indiana, however I will make the hour drive just to eat at this place again! See More
Amy Wickens
· September 4, 2017
Service was slow, waited an hour for food and then it was cold. It's a shame as it is beautiful but need to work out service issues or it will be all for nothing.
Tara Obermeyer
· April 9, 2017
Our party of four was pleasantly surprised with our lunches. We had the BLT, fish sandwich, mushroom soup with brussels sprouts, and chicken salad. Would recommend each of those to anyone who's hungry.
Rodney Jones
· May 7, 2017
My wife, myself and another couple ate there Friday night the 5th and everything was very good and the service was excellent. We all ordered off the German menu, a delightful treat and our waitress was stellar.
Chris Adams
· July 7, 2017
Four of us dined here. Three loved there meals. I had the French onion soup and I would suggest they find a new recipe because it wasn't good at all. The bar was great and we loved the renovations!
Jenny Durbin
· August 23, 2017
The Date and Pear Salad with Pomegranate Dressing, while fresh and chilled to perfection, is misnamed. It comes with a single sliver of date and fewer than 5 pear matchstick slices. Our server did begrudgingly bring a date. :-/
Kathleen McMenamy Bohman
· August 19, 2017
We had wonderful evening and delicious meal in the beautiful bar room. Thank you to our server Emily!
Brian Rennekamp
· April 13, 2017
Glad to have finally been able to visit The Sherman twice this week, and both experiences were fantastic!
Lunch was delicious, service was prompt and our waitre...ss was friendly and eager to please.
A few days later we visited the bar for drinks and light bar fare. Food and drinks were excellent and affordable. Great atmosphere and top notch bar staff - I highly recommend a visit, we will be back soon! See More
See All
Posts

We're excited to invite you to our Saturday Night in The Heartland, featuring Heartland Acoustics, Nick and Miranda. We hope you'll hurry on over and grab a good seat to enjoy a warm, beautiful Indian summer night with us. Select from four flavors of cold frozen Margaritas or six German beers.

Image may contain: text

Announcing The Sherman Biergarten 2017 Photo Album Contest!

New photos will be posted every weekend, so check back often! On October 31st, the person who has been tagged in the most photos will win a $100 Gift card, a bottle of wine, and two nights in our Chancellor King Suite.

See who is playing at The-Sherman.com/Events....
Some restrictions on dates may apply. Valid through 12.31.2018.

See More
See All
Videos
Lunch at The Sherman
121
6
See All
Posts